A Dive into the Unexplainable: My Thoughts on Starling
There’s a magnetic pull about books that evoke a sense of wonder, and Starling by Kristen Ciccarelli certainly weighed heavy on my anticipation meter. With its lush cover art and a premise that promised a charming blend of magical realism, I was eager to escape into the enigmatic town of Darling. However, after reading, I found myself with mixed feelings—a reaction that seems to echo the magic and mystery the novel itself portrays.
At its core, Starling tells the tale of Delta and her family, who exist on the outskirts of Darling, a town shrouded in oddities known only to a chosen few. Their lives take an unexpected turn when a boy—something not quite human—falls from the sky. The story intertwines themes of belonging, identity, and the tension between the familiar and the unknown. As Delta grapples with her family’s challenges, including a father lost to a mysterious door, the atmosphere thickens with the strangeness that surrounds her.
One of the novel’s strongest points is Ciccarelli’s evocative writing style. The thematic richness reminded me of a curious blend of Good Omens and classic children’s tales. The descriptions of Delta’s home—a living entity in itself—gave me the sensation of stepping into a magical bubble. It felt almost like watching the intricate cogs of a machine come to life, albeit one I could never fully see. This atmospheric quality made for an absorbing reading experience, but I couldn’t shake the feeling that within those enchanting layers, some elements remained frustratingly elusive.
Speaking of puzzling elements, the story misled my expectations from the start. Initially marketed as a subtle exploration of magic and change, I was surprised to discover its underlying sci-fi roots—more akin to ET than Stardust. This shift in tone felt jarring at times, especially with the introduction of additional POVs, particularly that of Starling. This character, meant to represent otherworldly allure, came across as pretentious—his immortal vibe didn’t resonate with me, pulling me away from the mesmerizing focus on Delta’s character and emotional journey.
Furthermore, I found myself wishing for a deeper dive into the world’s magic, which felt more like a whisper than a roar. The hints of enchantment were captivating, but ultimately left me wanting more substantial engagement with the fantastical aspects of Darling. I also struggled with character dynamics, particularly regarding the romance and Delta’s friend Bee, who often served as an obstacle rather than a meaningful addition to Delta’s life.
Despite these critiques, there are undeniable sparks of brilliance in Ciccarelli’s narrative. The author’s capability to weave an enchanting tapestry filled with emotionally charged moments and unique plot mechanics is commendable. I genuinely feel that with different character choices or a more concentrated focus on magic, this story could resonate even more profoundly.
I would recommend Starling to readers who enjoy atmospheric tales and are intrigued by stories that meander through the peculiarities of small towns. If the notion of an immortal boy with a complicated history entices you, then this book might just be your cup of tea. While the journey left me with mixed emotions, I appreciate the nuances of storytelling and depth within the characters. For that reason, I look forward to what Kristen Ciccarelli will conjure up next.